Taylor Swift Unplugged: The Psychology of Her True Fans

Source: Brian Friedman / Shutterstock

Most of us admire someone in music, sports, or the arts. From Dublin to Dubai, Rome to Rio, Swiftmania has now become contagious across five continents. Stadiums sold out as millions flocked to grab tickets. Ticketmaster estimates 14 million users fought for 625,000 tickets on the 152-show Eras tour.

It’s definitely now a “thing.” Glitter eye shadow, pink hats, and friendship bracelets appear everywhere. And the appeal appears age-agnostic, with Prince William, Paul McCartney, and Tom Cruise seen shaking it off at Wembley Arena.

It’s a cultural movement but also a commercial business. Thirty-four-year-old Swift boasts an $80-million real estate portfolio and became the first artist to be valued at $1.1 billion for music alone. It's inevitable to some, indescribable to others. Although Swift is as tuned into her fans as other artists, more fans tuned into her.

Is it the 13 Grammy award-winning music, the 5-foot-11-inch messenger, or the angst-filled messages? What explains the unbridled adoration of a stranger with relatively limited—if unrivaled and impressive—life experience?

6 Psychological Factors Behind Swiftmania

As a behavioural scientist, I think Swiftmania can be explained by six psychological factors:

1. Social Identity: We all derive identity and self-esteem from being members of groups such as a football team, political party, or religious order. Groups foster a sense of belonging, collective identity, and connection with similar others, Swift's fan base, referred to as "Swifties," forms a strong global community and shared identity that fosters loyalty in a perpetual cycle of reinforcement. Similar to "Swifties," Lady Gaga's "Little Monsters," Katy Perry's "KatyCats," or Beyoncé’s "Beyhive," this fan base constitutes a large global tribe who identifies with her message.
2. Positive Escapism: All types of fandom allow individuals an escape from routine and the stresses of daily life. It’s no different from losing yourself in the world of "Harry Potter," "Star Wars," "Game of Thrones," or "Lord of the Rings." These fictional worlds provide adventure and excitement that help you temporarily disconnect. Engaging with your preferred TV or Netflix show, record album, or Spotify list offers a break from reality, providing welcome relief and entertainment. A danger exists when these become an emotional crutch rather than coping with life.
3. Nostalgia: Fandom is deeply rooted in your personal history. Experiences associated with your #1 artist or bands often evoke sentimental feelings of nostalgia. Swift's music can evoke memories tied to specific times in your life, enhancing connectivity. It explains why Mick Jagger and Bruce Springsteen might go back on tour years later. Recapturing forgotten sentiments is as much for the artist as for the fan. It is as emotional as it is commercial. You also manage to preserve history through collectible souvenirs in the form of behavioral residue.
4. Self-Belief Consistency: Swift’s public stances on political, artistic, and social matters resonate positively with fans who share her views, reinforcing their commitment and, above all, their admiration. Taylor Swift took control of her music rights with a strong sense of direction. Not all can say that. And she knows how to apologize. Like all of us, fans seek consistency in beliefs and attitudes. Like abuse victims, die-hard fans rationalize and defend in times of underperformance or bad behavior to avoid cognitive dissonance.
5. Parasocial Relationships: Fans often develop one-sided connections with TV characters, influencers, or cherished teams. These parasocial relationships provide a feeling of pseudo-intimacy and companionship, fulfilling needs without the complexities of real-life interactions. Fans feel they have a personal relationship, which can spiral into dangerous territory when people can’t distinguish between fantasy and reality. For instance, John Hinckley Jr. was obsessed with actress Jodie Foster and attempted to assassinate President Ronald Reagan to gain her attention. It also explains why you may cry at funerals of public figures like Queen Elizabeth II. Most true Swifties respect and feel protective over their idol.
6. Social Proof: Column inches and popularity drive curiosity, leading more people to check out the trend. Swift's lyrics reflect personal experiences and vulnerabilities about heartbreak, betrayal, and growth. Fans empathize and see themselves in her music. Her talk of heartbreak helps people heal in a supportive movement and inspires resilience and self-belief. Like Adele, also known for emotionally charged music, fans likely think “She’s like me” or “She hears me.”

While most artists write about feelings, timing is everything. Today, many young people battle cruel social media, many feeling anxious and unheard. Swift’s authenticity is a trademark that others seek to emulate. Irish songstress Sinéad O’Connor reflected a similar brand authenticity, albeit in a different style. However, don’t forget social media, which partly explains Swift’s 550 million followers and Cristiano Ronaldo’s 911 million.

As I explain in my book, TUNE IN: How to Make Smarter Decisions in a Noisy World, those who tune in to others do a lot better, gain more influence, and are more successful than those who don't. When you tune out, you not only lose personally and professionally but so do those around you. Superstars get this—from the 1950s' Elvis to the 1960s' Beatles, 1970s' Abba, or 1980s' Michael Jackson.

Understanding intense fan group dynamics and shared beliefs partly explains the allure of all-consuming cults and even conspiracy theories. Seeing others endorse ideas or idols can make them appear more credible and attractive, expanding adoption, appeal, and spread. Of course, both fandom and cults exploit confirmation bias where individuals confirm existing beliefs. Yet fandom still carries distinct psychological benefits.

In case you can’t decide whether to identify as a Swiftie or not, I outline several behavioral techniques to overcome indecision in my TEDx talk. Understanding why Taylor Swift is a significant phenomenon gives us another lens with which to view the world—a world of those who tune in to certain identities and those who tune out.