Skip to main content

Verified by Psychology Today


The Conundrum of Overusing Kindness

Explore the depths of child behavior.

Key points

  • Instead of attributing children's actions to unkindness, we must embrace a more nuanced perspective.
  • Misbehavior often stems from stressors beyond their control.
  • Demanding school life can drain kids' mental resilience, leading to outbursts.
  • Social pressure in schools can overwhelm introverted kids.

Reflecting on my journey through education, I've come to deeply understand the pivotal role kindness plays in shaping children's behaviour. It's often portrayed as the ultimate solution to the challenges educators and parents face.

However, becoming a parent has made me question whether our relentless emphasis on kindness might sometimes miss the mark.

While I've always believed in the transformative power of kindness, I've also learned that its promotion isn't always a straightforward remedy. The complexities of child behaviour extend far beyond simple acts of kindness or unkindness, urging us to dig deeper to grasp the underlying causes of misbehaviour.

In my exploration of these complexities, I've uncovered several overlooked factors contributing to behavioural challenges in children.

Ego Depletion

The demanding nature of school life can take a toll on children's mental well-being, resulting in what some psychologists call ego depletion. This phenomenon (which has been challenged in recent years) describes the depletion of cognitive resources after prolonged periods of self-regulation. Suppressing emotions or thoughts can theoretically drain these reserves, leading to behavioural outbursts.

I recall navigating the labyrinth of my school life 40 years ago. There were moments when I longed for the comfort of home, yet I felt compelled to maintain a facade of composure in the classroom. Each instance of burying my true feelings beneath a veneer of conformity seemed to chip away at my mental resilience, leaving me vulnerable to sudden outbursts and frustrations. It was a delicate balancing act, trying to navigate the tumultuous waters of school life while tending to the needs of my psyche.

Additionally, some research has highlighted a link between ego depletion and glucose levels in the bloodstream. Children's poor dietary habits or inadequate nutrition can exacerbate this depletion, amplifying the likelihood of disruptive behaviour. Thus, attributing misbehaviour solely to unkindness overlooks the intricate interplay between physiological and environmental factors.

Social Interaction Pressures

In the bustling hallways of educational institutions, introverted children often find themselves drowned out by the din of social interaction. The constant buzz of social engagement can feel stifling for these children, who find solace in solitude. Neglecting their need for quiet introspection can worsen behavioural challenges, irrespective of their innate kindness.

My journey as an introverted child resonates with memories of feeling overwhelmed amidst a sea of voices. Asserting my need for solitude often felt like swimming against societal expectations.

This is precisely why introverted children must have some breathing space during the day. Some schools have recognised this need and created serene "nurture gardens" where children can enter nature's calm embrace to find their centre again. And in other places, they've set up cosy relaxation spots, giving children a quiet corner to unwind and take a break from the hustle and bustle of school life.

Teachers and parents play a pivotal role in navigating these tumultuous waters, offering respite through quiet spaces and moments of reflection. By honouring our children's diverse temperaments, we pave the way for a more inclusive educational landscape where kindness extends beyond mere words to encompass the nurturing of individual spirits.

Window of Tolerance

In the heart of every child lies a delicate balance, a threshold known as the "window of tolerance." When stressors breach this threshold, the gentle rhythms of emotion can give way to a disruption of anxiety and unrest, regardless of children's inherent kindness.

In my journey, I've experienced the narrow confines of my window of tolerance, where even the slightest breeze could send waves crashing against the shores of my soul. As I've grown into adulthood, I've learned to navigate these turbulent waters gracefully. Yet, the journey can be treacherous for children who are still finding their footing.

Recognising and accommodating these differences in tolerance levels is essential to creating a nurturing environment conducive to emotional well-being. Through understanding and empathy, rather than kindness-related judgment, we can offer a lifeline to those teetering on the edge of emotional unrest, guiding them back to calmer waters.

In fostering kindness, it's crucial to pause and ponder our course. Are we genuinely cultivating kindness when we unwittingly label children as unkind? This occurs each time we admonish a child to be kind in response to misbehaviour. In doing so, we're failing to exhibit kindness ourselves.

Misbehaviour among children may stem from various factors, including their inability to cope with specific stressors inherent to the school environment, prolonged periods of self-regulation, or individual personality traits such as introversion. These underlying causes often overshadow any deliberate intent of unkindness. Given these complexities, it becomes crucial to reassess our approach to addressing misbehaviour in educational settings.

Instead of hastily attributing children's actions to a lack of kindness, we must embrace a more nuanced perspective. Perhaps it's time to recognise that asking children to be constantly kind may not always be appropriate or beneficial. Instead, we should be selective in our expectations, understanding that children may need different support and guidance tailored to their unique circumstances and challenges.

More from Jolanta Burke Ph.D.
More from Psychology Today